Skip to main content
Democrats win Silver seat, Skelos race too close to call
Email share

Two special elections were also held Tuesday, to fill the seats vacated by the two former legislative leaders, who were both convicted of felony corruption and had to resign. The Assembly race was won by a Democrat, in the Senate, Republicans are asking for a hand count of paper ballots, while the Democrat has declared victory.

In the Assembly race in lower Manhattan, Democrat Alice Cancel won the seat held by former Speaker Sheldon Silver. Silver is awaiting sentencing on multiple corruption convictions.  Cancel, who was chosen for the seat with the help of Silver’s former top aide and a Democratic club close to the former Speaker, beat Working Families Party candidate and legislative staffer , Yuh Line Niou, Republican Lester Chang and  Green party candidate Dennis Levy.

In the Senate contest to fill the seat vacated by former Senate Leader Dean Skelos, who is also facing a prison term, along with his son, for corruption, the Democrat,  Todd Kaminsky is ahead by one-point. Kaminsky  has declared victory. But Republican candidate Chris McGrath says the race is too close yet to call and has asked for  a hand count of the paper ballots.

“ We expected this to be close. It is too close to call tonight. And hopefully when everything is counted, we’re going to prevail, “ McGrath told supporters early Wednesday morning.

Kaminski, an Assemblyman and former prosecutor who helped put former Senate Leader Pedro Espada behind bars, says if he’d had more time to campaign, his margin of victory might have been higher.

“My assembly district is a third of the area. A lot of people I don’t know, a lot of places I don’t know, so there’s only so much time, especially when you’re in session in Albany to get everywhere,” Kaminsky said.

If Kaminsky’s lead holds, Democrats will gain the numerical majority in the Senate, but not necessarily take control of the chamber from the Republicans because one Democrat , Senator Simcha Felder of Brooklyn caucuses with the GOP, and is not expected to switch allegiance any time soon. Five other Democrats are members of the Independent Democratic Conference. The IDC has in the past formed a joint ruling coalition with the Republicans, leaving the regular Democrats out of power.

Current Senate Majority Leader John Flanagan - downplayed  the significance of the potential power struggle, saying it’s all about local issues.

“It’s more about what does this mean for things like school aid, environmental funding, funding for transportation,” said Flanagan. “That is what is the most important thing.”

McGrath , during the campaign, said electing Democrat Kaminsky would  result in New York City interests in school aid and other areas overriding Long Island concerns.

And even before the Senate race is officially settled, there’s already action to begin the next round of voting. In Sheldon Silver’s old district , a past challenger to the former Speaker, Paul Newell, has already said he intends to challenge winner Alice Cancel in a September primary.