• Click to contribute to WMHT
  • Click to make/update a sustaining contribution to WMHT
  • Click to join the WMHT e-news mailing list

State Education officials say they are not lowering teacher standards

Last Updated by Karen DeWitt on

The state Board of Regents is taking steps to make it easier for teachers to become certified in New York. But the state education commissioner denies that it’s a lessening of requirements.

Prospective teachers in New York will no longer have to score as high on a qualifying test in order to obtain teaching certificates, now that the Board of Regents has agreed to lower the passing score on a test required for a teaching certificate. Until now, a score of 41 out of a total of 75 was required on the exams, known as the edTPA, for educative Teacher Performance Assessment. Beginning in January, the passing score will be three points lower, at 38, increasing to a score of 40 by January 2022. If candidates score just a couple of points below the passing grade, they can also be approved to teach, in some special circumstances, under a safety net system. State Education Commissioner Mary Ellen Elia says it’s not a lowering of standards.

“If anybody is saying ‘you’re dropping standards’, that’s really not the case,” Elia said.

 Elia says other states that have adopted the test have also reduced the passing score.

Jolene DiBrango, Vice President with the teachers’ union, New York State United Teachers, says that the lower score requirements are fixing problems with the tests, which were created by the Stanford University Center for Assessment, and removing “cumbersome barriers”.

“I don’t believe it’s a lowering of standards,” DiBrango said.

Commissioner Elia says the tweaking of the teacher certification process is in sharp contrast to a proposal being considered by the State University of New York Board of Trustees Charter Schools Committee. That proposal would significantly alter standards required for teachers at charter schools, in some cases requiring only 30 hours of classroom experience in order to be qualified to teach.

Commissioner Elia, as well as Regents Chancellor Betty Rosa have sent their complaints to the SUNY Committee, which is holding a public comment period on the proposed changes. She says there is “major concern across the state”.

“If you’re talking about a lowering of standards, I think you clearly need to look at that proposal,” said Elia. “And know that that’s exactly what it is.”   

Under state law, both the state Department of Education and SUNY are allowed to oversee the opening and regulation of charter schools. Schools can be authorized by one entity or the other. And SUNY and the state education department do not have to have the same rules and regulations for the charter schools.

NYSUT’s DiBrango says the SUNY proposal is a “watering down” of teacher requirements. She says there are already alternative paths in New York to certify teachers with nontraditional backgrounds. And she says the lowered teacher standards could disproportionately affect children of color and from families dealing with poverty.

“You need multiple tools in your toolbox in order to support those children and provide a full education to them,” DiBrango said.  “If you don’t have the proper training, you’re sending people into those classrooms who are simply not good enough to be in front of those kids.”

Charter schools have said they are suffering from a teacher shortage, and need different rules in order to recruit teachers. The SUNY Committee will take up the proposal on October 11th.

Executive Director of the SUNY Charter Schools Institute, Susie Miller Carello responded to Elia's remarks and took a shot at the education department 's track record.

“We welcome all substantive comments on the draft regulations. Commissioner Elia’s departments’ own data indicates that 100% of teachers in Buffalo and Rochester have a valid teaching certificate, yet 18% of students in Buffalo and only 8% of students in Rochester score at or above grade level," Carello said. "Given that data, I wonder why the State Education Department is not asking itself why certification does not necessarily result in great teaching? Meanwhile, SUNY authorized charter schools get 70%, 80%, and even 90% of students up to grade level.”

Support Provided By
Image - thirteen_wnet_nynow_sponsor.jpg Image - thirteen_wnet_nynow_sponsor.jpg

In Partnership With

Times Union Partnership

Listen to Podcasts

PBS Newshour AdPBS Newshour AdPBS Newshour